@Jazzy
Really? Not one yes in that sea of nopes? So in an average sample of 15 dudes there wouldn't be one acceptable guy? I know you girls have wildly different standards than us guys but isn't that a little harsh?
For the average guy it would be the complete opposite. In a room full of women our thoughts would be:
"I'd do her, I'd do her, I'd do her, I'D DEFINITIVELY TAP THAT ASS, I'd do her, I'd do her, I'd do her, meeeeeh not my type but I'd still do her, I'd do her, I'd do her with a bag over her head, I'd do her, I WOULD WORSHIP HER LIKE A GODDESS I'd do her, nope... well... maaaybe... no, no, I stand my my nope"

I'm not trying to be sleazy, I'm just calling it like it is

This is the way the
average guy thinks. I put the emphasis on average so I don't get a bunch of white knight douchebags saying "I don't think like that! I'm so enlightened that I don't care about a woman's appearance at all! I'd date a rhinoceros if it had a beautiful soul!"
@LadySelene
Your advice is indisputable. Even if it's a bit cliche, it's a cliche because it's correct. The problem is that it applies only after you've passed the first hurdle. The hurdle of being attractive/interesting/appealing enough so that the girl will give you the time of day and a chance to show how respectful, communication savvy and full of love you are.
Sure, what you said is all you need to worry about if you want to keep a girl but isn't really useful advice for getting a girl. You girls might not be as shallow and appearance focused as us guys, but you still won't talk to every Quasimodo who approaches you because, hey, he might be beautiful on the inside and a really good guy. Just like us, you still need that initial spark of attraction to get you going and to get you to give a guy a chance.
So maybe the question shouldn't be what goth chicks want in a romantic partner but what goth chicks find attractive in a guy.