I loved Fairy Tail! Maybe it's not in my top 10 (the action sequences could be a little more elaborate and the plot points a bit less "cliche-y") but I can never say no to hundreds of episodes of wizards, dragons and adorable little talking cats

I love anime. I rewatched Full Metal Alchemist (both the old series and Brotherhood) and Ao no Exorcist, and now I´m thinking about Arslan Senki, Wolfs Rain or Cowboy Bebop (I used to watch it long ago, but never seen it all) until there will be new episodes from Nanatsu no Taizai.
I´m currently making an anime list of "want to watch", so thanks for all suggestion I found here. Most of them I´ve already saw.

I like some of the suggestions here, will be sure to check them out.
I prefer dramas, usually in the sci-fi or dark fantasy genres, with the most recent one being the
Monogatari series.

At first it appears as a regular teenage boy meets girl, than another, and pretty soon we have a harem situation.
Later the story get interesting with character development and vampires and spirits.

I love... pokemon:D *hides*

Some of you ladies might appreciate reverse-harem titles, where the female protagonist gets to choose.
My recommendations: Fushigi Yuugi, Hakuouki, Amnesia & Uta no Prince-sama.